Name: Picture This: That time an LI house of horrors became an urban legend
Uploaded: 2025-10-29T09:00:00Z
Duration: 1 min 54 s
Description: NewsdayTV's Macy Egeland looks back at the events that led a Long Island home to become known as "The Amityville Horror House."

Newsday TV

NewsdayTV Top Item

In Dec. 2024, an East Patchogue teen went missing for 25 days. NewsdayTV&#39;s Ken Buffa spoke with reporter Shari Einhorn about the girl, her life, the search and some of Long Island&#39;s dark secrets the investigation exposed.

Long Island

Investigations

FLMISSING251204_video

The Backstory: Missing and Unprotected

onecms:bcb625d9-eb7b-454a-b13c-a7a23c8a426b

Newsday

'Really, really tough stuff to talk about'

10092025_Matt_FLMISSING2510_Backstory_East_Patchogue_missing_teen_Buffa_Einhorn_Paraskevas_V11.00_00_30_09.Still014.jpg

In Dec. 2024, an East Patchogue teen went missing for 25 days. NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa spoke with reporter Shari Einhorn about the girl, her life, the search and some of Long Island's dark secrets the investigation exposed.

History

LIROSES251208_video

84th anniversary of attack on Pearl Harbor commemorated at LI museum

Farmingdale

onecms:f2489d3c-f41a-4f7f-b836-af1cc6b85ede

'I just did what I had to do'

onecms_9177402b-32ba-4ad5-8ecc-eec9511e2b36_60ddb381-eec9-4e55-ab29-e3981442c444.jpg

A solemn ceremony was held at the American Airpower Museum in Farmingdale where veterans were honored and roses were blessed and flown to the Statue of Liberty. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie reports.

The first naturalization ceremony since the government shutdown was held in Central Islip, where 86 people from 37 countries became U.S.&nbsp;citizens. NewsdayTV&#39;s Ken Buffa reports.

Suffolk

LICEREMONY251205_video

86 people become U.S. citizens at ceremony in Central Islip

Central Islip

onecms:5bf17526-6e9d-4667-bc4e-e29c407d9407

'I finally accomplished that goal'

onecms_b1d5644b-f3ad-4c15-937f-e2e0e7766afc_35bab6d8-4277-4083-b1a6-54eea9b0067b.jpg

The first naturalization ceremony since the government shutdown was held in Central Islip, where 86 people from 37 countries became U.S. citizens. NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa reports.

A rehearsal was held on Monday at the United Methodist Church of Hempstead for an upcoming gospel concert that&nbsp;will raise funds for local social justice movements.

Nassau

LIGOSPEL251207_video

LI gospel choir prepares for fundraising concert

Hempstead

onecms:d05097cf-accc-4512-a567-82c8a4d1efcf

'Empowered to use our voice'

onecms_aa40b3bb-ac64-421c-a37f-70105bd6f09b_ea9763c7-5f72-48f0-bbb5-27be9f6c87f5.jpg

onecms_9fe0b8ec-4068-421f-8962-feee0fe32e9d_283893b0-a889-4409-8ca6-be43732aaf33.jpg

A rehearsal was held on Monday at the United Methodist Church of Hempstead for an upcoming gospel concert that will raise funds for local social justice movements.

A Wantagh mosque&rsquo;s appeal to move a fence is drawing&nbsp;community opposition. NewsdayTV&#39;s Virginia Huie reports.&nbsp;

Towns

TOMOSQUE251205_video

Hearing held over LI mosque's appeal to move fence

Hempstead Town

Wantagh

onecms:8facdd05-277f-4344-90e9-12ed17d5e706

'For safety reasons and religious privacy reasons'

onecms_bf1f156b-6f33-4868-8494-25a2d5cc6e83_18777862-b8dd-4085-a35e-1f8868522471.jpg

A Wantagh mosque's appeal to move a fence is drawing community opposition. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie reports.

Filmmaker Ed Burns&nbsp;returns to his childhood home in Valley Stream&nbsp;to talk about&nbsp;his 1995 classic, &quot;The Brothers McMullen,&quot;&nbsp;and 2025 follow-up, &quot;The Family McMullen.&quot;

Entertainment

Movies

ETBURNS251207_video

LI filmmaker returns home for 'The Family McMullen'

Valley Stream

onecms:11812b7d-ed39-4962-848e-ae30c65ad2ce

'House in Valley Stream, served as the inspiration for all of this work'

onecms_f108b42a-8820-4659-a345-1c6ba7095339_3f00b205-ef81-4cb7-ace4-ac7c94be1000.jpg

Filmmaker Ed Burns returns to his childhood home in Valley Stream to talk about his 1995 classic, "The Brothers McMullen," and 2025 follow-up, "The Family McMullen."

Montauk has a lot to offer, not just in the summer, but all year round. Newsday&#39;s travel reporter, Carissa Kellman, visits &quot;The End.&quot;

Travel

TROFFSEASON251212_video

'The End' of LI, without the crowds: Montauk in winter

Montauk

onecms:7effa12d-e13e-4096-abff-661bb3a7d6a7

Offseason in Montauk: Holiday lights, lobster rolls and lighthouse views

onecms_cdcc476f-2a8d-448f-a4c0-d0e7e45585ac_5be5a7cb-3d92-47a5-ba0e-6669aa7cf597.jpg

Montauk has a lot to offer, not just in the summer, but all year round. Newsday's travel reporter, Carissa Kellman, visits "The End."

A Newsday analysis found Suffolk ticketing for safety violations lags New York State, while Nassau remains below pre-pandemic levels. NewsdayTV&#39;s Doug Geed reports.

Transportation

liTICKET251130_video

Is there enough traffic enforcement on LI?

Yaphank

onecms:5be01b26-71bc-4b31-8be8-c49f20e9cef9

'It's extremely important writing those tickets'

onecms_f38257da-da62-4865-8bfa-b27575f840ef_f9234034-87fb-4cce-9f33-5960152ef1cb.jpg

A Newsday analysis found Suffolk ticketing for safety violations lags New York State, while Nassau remains below pre-pandemic levels. NewsdayTV's Doug Geed reports.

A man and woman were found dead at A&amp;A Italian Deli &amp; Pizza in Plainedge.&nbsp;NewsdayTV&#39;s Ken Buffa has more.&nbsp;

Crime

liSTABBING251205_video

Two people fatally stabbed at Plainedge deli

Bethpage

onecms:44b939be-bc0e-41a7-8670-c3aafc200475

'I stabbed my parents'

onecms_34152f64-aa07-487c-8b47-fdad30ada04e_414cb7ad-e6dc-4d13-bdc2-2a15946a996f.jpg

A man and woman were found dead at A&A Italian Deli & Pizza in Plainedge. NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa has more.

From local treasures to this year&#39;s hottest toys, NewsdayTV&#39;s team has a tour of our 2025 Ultimate Holiday Gift Guide.

Things to Do

Holidays

Winter Holidays

FLGIFTGUIDE251205_video

Newsday's Ultimate Holiday Gift Guide

Stony Brook

Cold Spring Harbor

Oceanside

onecms:54fa3f84-7116-4b47-a12c-58dea5018902

Step inside Newsday's Ultimate Holiday Gift Guide

DJI_20251126103521_0722_D.MP4.15_28_32_29.Still001.jpg

From local treasures to this year's hottest toys, NewsdayTV's team has a tour of our 2025 Ultimate Holiday Gift Guide.

NewsdayTV&#39;s Ken Buffa visits Made by Michael Russo in Cold Spring Harbor to learn some tips and tricks from a professional gift wrapper.

FLGIFT251209_video

LI Works: Wrap your holiday gifts like a pro

onecms:eff3f1da-e217-4c6a-b8c5-d3db1c072a1f

'You should really amp it up'

DJI_20251201145527_0030_D.MP4.22_50_21_03.Still001.jpg

NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa visits Made by Michael Russo in Cold Spring Harbor to learn some tips and tricks from a professional gift wrapper.

NewsdayTV&#39;s Ken Buffa takes a deep dive into the grilled cheese smashburger at&nbsp;No Good Burger Joint in Rockville Centre.

FeedMe

Feed Me TV

FLSMASH251204_video

Trendy Bites: Viral grilled cheese smashburger

Rockville Centre

onecms:33253986-6819-4ec3-a15a-900a1ba0724b

'Let the juices and onions flow'

DJI_20251008135855_0272_D.MP4.22_01_18_09.Still001.jpg

NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa takes a deep dive into the grilled cheese smashburger at No Good Burger Joint in Rockville Centre.

Kevin McDonald was&nbsp;sentenced in the rape of a 14-year-old Patchogue girl who went missing for 25 days last year. NewsdayTV&#39;s&nbsp;Virginia Huie reports.&nbsp;

liMISSING251204_video

LI man sentenced in missing girl case

Patchogue

Bellport

long island

onecms:cb9c8a3d-e595-42d8-97ec-3ddb626721f0

'He took full responsibility for what transpired'

onecms_7cebbc05-3755-453f-ba2b-09df8f9174db_a74e803f-b1bc-4b12-837b-2b16d12e8c07.jpg

onecms_124f06b5-46c8-4ec4-998e-b7500c52ecf6_b55a8a4a-620d-426f-bf27-f540e24f8557.jpg

Kevin McDonald was sentenced in the rape of a 14-year-old Patchogue girl who went missing for 25 days last year. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie reports.

NewsdayTV&#39;s Elisa DiStefano visits Jessy&#39;s Pastries in Oceanside to learn how to make&nbsp;alfajores, which are dulce de leche-filled Peruvian cookies.

gg25_sweets_video

Dulce de leche cookies at Jessy's Pastries

onecms:79023efb-db1b-402b-8818-5a5412a97ea5

'It's like a shortbread cookie, so it just melts in your mouth'

DJI_20251201101607_0074_D.MP4.18_16_08_00.Still002.jpg

NewsdayTV's Elisa DiStefano visits Jessy's Pastries in Oceanside to learn how to make alfajores, which are dulce de leche-filled Peruvian cookies.

On the latest episode of &quot;Sarra Sounds Off,&quot; Newsday&#39;s Gregg Sarra takes&nbsp;a look back at the Long Island Championships,&nbsp;plus Jared Valluzzi and Jonathan Ruban with the plays of the week.

Sports

High School

SKSARRA251204_video

Sarra Sounds Off, Ep. 13: Recap of Long Island Football Championships

Garden City

Massapequa

Bayport

Sayville

onecms:83eaa829-bcb0-468a-ba6f-fa22b866c6e5

Sarra Sounds Off, Ep. 13: LIC highlights

12042025_Greg_ep13_Sarra_Sounds_off_Staff.00_00_14_06.Still004.jpg

PLAYS OF THE WEEK VERT.00_00_17_22.Still001.jpg

On the latest episode of "Sarra Sounds Off," Newsday's Gregg Sarra takes a look back at the Long Island Championships, plus Jared Valluzzi and Jonathan Ruban with the plays of the week.

The annual &ldquo;Pennies for Charity&rdquo; report found professional fundraisers took a big chunk out of donations last year. NewsdayTV&rsquo;s Virginia Huie has more.

News

Region/State

LICHARITY251203_video

'Pennies for Charity' under controversy after 2025 report

onecms:d71068c2-718e-4fdc-b53b-df353286165c

'That's not right'

onecms_56ac5a0c-e69b-4ee7-94f0-2e30e455b96e_0441e12f-ac68-4a5a-9987-0ed6a0473d6f.jpg

The annual "Pennies for Charity" report found professional fundraisers took a big chunk out of donations last year. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie has more.

&quot;It&#39;s not good enough&quot; said Giants general manager Joe Schoen on Tuesday as he spoke for the first time about moving on from head coach Brian Daboll and getting the franchise back in the proper direction.

Football

New York Giants

spGIANTS251203_video

Giants GM Joe Schoen looking to get team back in the right direction

onecms:d3fe3f8a-9d0c-4b8f-a9fe-fb397b6da7fd

Giants GM: '2 wins is not where we want to be right now'

onecms_74b0c22d-59c1-4868-bfbc-a27ec0bc99b9_ac48586a-5624-4201-9e29-c34de48c2bc6.jpg

"It's not good enough" said Giants general manager Joe Schoen on Tuesday as he spoke for the first time about moving on from head coach Brian Daboll and getting the franchise back in the proper direction.

Fire officials demonstrate how fast a Christmas tree can become a major fire and share tips on&nbsp;preventing disaster.

FLTREE251203_video

Christmas tree safety tips

onecms:630b3a94-b521-48f4-9f24-d050147df5cd

Watch how fast a Christmas tree fire can spread

onecms_ce31a8b2-668f-4b89-9863-4a142889cdc6_b13495be-09a6-4381-8b80-8fbb53e92049.jpg

Fire officials demonstrate how fast a Christmas tree can become a major fire and share tips on preventing disaster.

NewsdayTV&#39;s Ken Buffa vists The Little Cigar Factory in Alberston to see what it takes to become a master roller.

FLCIGAR251202_video

LI Works: Cigar roller wraps tobacco with tradition

onecms:a42d1169-125a-42bc-9ffb-3635466cc9d3

'There's definitely an art and a method to making the perfect hand-rolled cigar.'

KB LI WORKS CIGARS studio.00_00_48_24.Still001.jpg

NewsdayTV's Ken Buffa vists The Little Cigar Factory in Alberston to see what it takes to become a master roller.

Nassau police say Michael Dotzler&rsquo;s disappearance is still an active missing person&#39;s case, while a private detective suspects foul play.&nbsp;NewsdayTV&#39;s&nbsp;Virginia Huie reports.&nbsp;

LICOLD251130_P94_H40_video

A court officer vanished nearly 2 years ago. His family hasn't given up hope for his return.

New York State

onecms:c1c71a79-3e43-419c-b198-25f484aa9ca8

'Where are you? Please come back to us.'

IMG_3557 (1).MOV.00_00_05_17.Still001.jpg

Nassau police say Michael Dotzler's disappearance is still an active missing person's case, while a private detective suspects foul play. NewsdayTV's Virginia Huie reports.

HOLIDAY SEASON 2025

FLEXIBLE SLOT

Ralph Macchio, star&nbsp;of &quot;The Karate Kid&quot; movies and the Netflix series &quot;Cobra Kai,&quot; made an appearance at this year&#39;s Huntington tree lighting.

flMACCHIO251202_video

Ralph Macchio hosts Huntington tree lighting

Huntington

onecms:5498786c-0f19-4cc3-9adf-4d5b32db0cea

'Karate Kid' helps Huntington kick off the holiday season

0F1A9785.MP4.02_28_05_18.Still001.jpg

Ralph Macchio, star of "The Karate Kid" movies and the Netflix series "Cobra Kai," made an appearance at this year's Huntington tree lighting.